A study of small caps listed on the Hong Kong exchange
Over the last couple of years much of my portfolio performance can be attributed to a few holdings which have 2-5x in a short period of time. The latest one being Modern Dental Group where the price recently just took off.
If you want to read my Modern Dental Group analysis just click here.
Discussing with other small cap value investors, investing in HK small caps can be a bit like tapping on the Heinz ketchup bottle. Stocks do nothing for years and then all return comes at once. I hadn’t really experienced it like that in the past but lately this resonates a lot with me. As you can see the price graph of Modern Dental above is was a grueling holding which went from 3 HKD down to just above 1 HKD. Consider that this happened in an environment where stock markets where extremely bullish. Then suddenly the stock just pops fantastic when it happens. I want to explore what drives these sudden burst of returns. How to catch them, how to act when they break out and also try to identify if and when its time to either reduce or sell your position. This is Part 1 which focuses mainly on how to catch these type of holdings.
Catching the Rocket
The very first step of enjoying the returns of a small cap that significantly re-rates is to actually be there when it happens. I have a number of stocks that I held and sold, just to see them sky-rocket later. Or stock that I held for a long time when they started to move upwards I was quick to sell and afterwards looking like a fool when the stock continued to double from my selling price. First step is to actually be there when the stock takes off. As we will see from a few examples of stock price graphs, its easier said than done.
Modern Dental was a success example, let’s look at some failures as there is probably more to learn from those. For the ones of you that have been reading the blog from the very beginning, you might remember this:
You can imagine I was pretty upset with my timing on this Chinese auto-dealer, even more so since the stock almost doubled again to ~9 HKD after my print screen from back then. But why did it go up, did anything change financially? The financials that were known at the time were the mid-year 2016 results.
Zhengtong Income Statement
Stock price graph:
Although 2016 mid year results showed a slight turn-around in revenue growth, when I sold my shares in late 2016 the market was as its most pessimistic. The market after that went ahead and repriced the stock to 4 HKD. With the 2016 full year results out with a decent 9.2% YoY Revenue increase but nothing really to write home about. Without any further improvements to the bottom line the stock went all the way to 6.8 HKD. At the 6.8 HKD price level the positive profit alert for first half of 2017 confirmed what the market already had significantly priced in – the turnaround in Operating Income was here. With the profit alert out the stock traded sideways until the actual semi-annual report was released and the stock afterwards peaked just below 9 HKD. A fantastic journey to have been on compared to the stock price of 2 HKD just one year earlier. Clearly there were a lot of people who understood the dynamics of the car dealer market much better than I did back then (and still do). They probably had leading indicators to track that the turn-around that was happening basically just when I sold my shares. They got more and more confident in the turnaround and bought up the stock – in the end they were proven right.
Lesson number #1: Don’t buy companies for the short term, where others have much better market insight.
I had no edge to invest in a China car dealership turnaround and this seems to have been a terrible business to invest in for the long term (mainly because they have taken on huge amounts of debt). The real conclusion must then be, rather that it was a shame I missed the rocket, I should never have bought this kind of company.
Lesson number #2: Don’t be sad for missing a company that sky-rockets upwards that doesn’t long term create shareholder value.
Value traps & multiple contraction pains
If we then move over to companies that have sound balance sheets, good businesses and valuations are reasonable, something that is good to own for the long term. The dream obviously is to find these companies early and cheap. Later have the market rocket them up to a much higher multiple. It sounds easy and great, there are a lot of troubles with that approach though.
Among my small caps and especially the ones listed in Emerging Markets, they often share some similar features. The feature that often lured me to buy them in the first place is their low valuation compared to their fairly attractive businesses. The problems arise when the market doesn’t give a damn about that I now bought into the company and the stock continues to trade cheaply – for years. Worse than that sometimes, the business does decently well, but the stock price goes even lower due to the multiple it trading at contracts further. This is to me the pain trade – the value trap. Being convinced that this is a “rocket” that has yet to lift off, but the market totally disregards your feelings and nobody is buying it. In the end it puts me in a tough spot if I should stay and endure the pain or allocate my capital somewhere we I actually get some returns, not just pain. Let’s look at some examples what pain actually looks like
Pain Trades (aka value traps)
Tianneng Power – Chinese battery producer
Imaging being bullish on EVs and battery cells for Solar energy storage back in 2016. Tianneng is a battery-cell producer making low costs batteries that mainly goes into battery driven Scooters etc (which has seen a huge upswing last few years). Let’s pretend we find this company trading at a low valuation in early 2016, showing good revenue growth and trading at a low EV/EBITDA multiple around 8x. I would have been a pretty happy camper taking a position in this in 2016. In fact back in 2016 I choose between investing in this company and Coslight another Chinese battery producer.
Seems like a solid investment case back in early 2016 right? Well, wrong. The company will in the coming five year continue to perform financially, but the stock market will punish you grossly. Your EV/EBITDA entry multiple of 8x will contract all the way down to below 1x. Imaging being right on the financials, but you get nothing because the multiple just keep contracting as fundamentals get better. So in the middle of a bull market where other EV plays and battery producers are taking new all time highs, we have this company trading below 1x its EBIT. And the share price has done nothing in these ~3-4 years.
Tianneng EV/EBIT multiple
The market changes its mind
Then finally after the Covid crash the market changes its mind on the company and send the stock-price (and the EV/EBIT multiple) through the roof in comparison where it traded just six months earlier. For the avid reader you might remember that I owned this for a short time around the Covid stock market crash. I sold some in the middle of the crash to buy companies I felt more sure off but manage to keep a small portion that turned into a nice profit.
Obviously a company trading at so low valuations most be controversial in some way. And indeed in 2020 a short report was released by Cloudy Thunder: Short report. They might be right long term, but the stock over 1 year later is still trading significantly higher than when the report was released. I’m sure not everything is great with the company, but personally since I owned this and looked at it in great detail, I’m not so sure the short guys are fully correct in their analysis either. Herein lies the opportunity of course, you can’t find a stock trading below 1x EBIT and the case is all roses and sunshine. For the ones willing to take the bet, the stock price went 5x from bottom to peak, even with a short report released “against you”. Good to note also is that the stock is nowhere near its 2016 multiple, the stock is only up because fundamentals improved tremendously, no multiple expansion at all has been enjoyed.
Tianneng share price
Another pain trade example – PAX Global
Since I written plenty about PAX and its my largest holding, I won’t go into all the details, but its also an example of a long history of pain holding this company. In this case I was lucky (and hopefully a little skillful) to get in just before the infliction point.
As you can see the multiple just kept contracting for years and in the 2020 March sell-off, the EV touched zero (MCAP = cash). Disregarding cash which might be locked up, also on a P/E basis the stock was trading below 5.
Meanwhile between 2016 and 2020 fundamentally the company has:
- Increased Revenue +94%
- Operating Income +65%
- Net Income +50%
It might seem easy in hindsight when the stock starts to perform that this was a clear winner to invest in. But sitting on a holding that goes down for years, while fundamentally it improves, is a very very strange feeling. The case got better, so should one buy more? But then you are adding to your losing positions, does not seem ideal. Have you misunderstood something that the market has caught wind of? Is it a fraud? When a company behaves like this your head gets filled with doubt if you really know what you are doing. This for sure happened to me with Modern Dental Group, which I sold down to a tiny position on these doubts. Luckily I rebought what I sold just at the infliction (had been better to never sell).
Ideas on how to catch the Rocket
I could go on with many more examples of rockets that taken off. But I wanted to share what I learned it terms of identifying a HK listed small cap that have the right set of characteristics to actually become a future rocket:
- Actually being a good business. It doesn’t necessarily need to be a great business (that’s too much to expect given the often very low valuations).
- Valuation being low with history of revenue growth. To get started with a list of stocks to dig deeper into, a simple stock screen is very useful here.
- Large enough market cap for institutional money to come in and push up the multiple. Often what happened with stocks that became value traps is that institutions offload and there really are no new institutional takers as the company market cap falls too low. The sweet-spot here for a rocket to take off is somewhere around 500-800m USD, depending a bit on free-float. As soon as the company hits around 1bn USD it suddenly pops up on EM managers screens for small-caps. Suddenly 4-5 managers in USA can decide to take a position, which they never would as long as the company was a 300-400m USD company.
- Value traps are often avoided by waiting until there is trigger in the company. There are many different kind of triggers though, quite often in HK a trigger is that the company in producing great results and it can no longer be ignored. Wait for what you believe is a trigger the market can no longer ignore.
- As we have seen the rockets often come from a track record of having been valued higher in the past and then slowly drifting lower over the years (or sideways with significantly improved fundamentals). This seems to create a setup where there is very little resistance on the upside, at least initially there are very few sellers. All weak hands have been washed out over the years and the ones left, are not selling just because the stock is up 30-40% from its lows. Situations like these seems ideal for a rocket revaluation. The momentum upwards then feeds interest also from HK local stock punters, which also jump on the bandwagon and further pumps up the price. Suddenly it can become quite a hot stock, from six months earlier being forgotten and trading with very thin liquidity.
These kind of characteristics are fertile ground for future rockets. The risk is that we rush into these stocks and are way too early. Early means that you have to sit through the pain trade, which I have now done multiple times (stocks like Dream International is still in pain mode). As we can see from many of these valuation graphs above, the multiple can go much lower than most of us think is possible/reasonable.
Part 2 will be about riding the rocket..
16 thoughts to “Part 1 – Catching the Value Rocket”
Cookpad Inc. (2193.T)
trading near cash
Hello, thank you very much for sharing. A very good source of learning to have come across this post.
Is part two available? I’ve looked for it but can’t find it
Give me a little bit of time and I will produce a Part 2 🙂
Hehe thanks. It seems to me that I became very anxious when reading the part 1. I will wait attentive.
Great post! Next time you may check with me for some local/mainland China “perceptions” for those rocketing candidates 😉 I could also benefit from some insights that I independently feel invest-able ( I did some investment first recommended by my ex-colleague and I never thought too much on so much pains…)
btw, I have a comprehensive deep learning AI fundamental reports covering 28 industries in A shares 4000+ stocks (long time ago I did mention this to you).
Your comments are welcome anytime if you have some China “perception” input! :). As a non-institutional investor my coverage through stock connect is really poor, so A-shares is less interesting.
Nice post. When to sell is the hardest part with these Hong Kong stocks. Take for example Consun, I could see it was clearly too cheap at 4-5x earnings. And now it is at 8x earnings, and I am wondering how much higher it can go. In the US that would clearly be a bargain, but in HK market you probably never get more than 10x, unless it really becomes a market darling, and then all of a sudden it can easily burst through to 20-30x earnings. I would add that when a sudden theme becomes hot, you can also see sudden re ratings. But they are usually temporary.
I noticed this when I analyzed David Webb’s investing track record. A lot of stocks he picked simply did well because they grew earnings and paid large dividends, there wasn’t a whole lot of multiple expansion above 10x earnings.
I have had good experiences with opportunistically selling out portions of my holdings as they go up though. Often a lot of these sudden spikes are temporary in the HK market. For every stock that rerates and stays up there, probably 4 or 5 of them fall back again. I think it is better to sell at least a portion of your position too soon than to stubbornly hold. Especially since there is an oversupply of cheap stocks in the HK market.
Great comment, you practically wrote half of my Part 2 post on riding the rocket 🙂
Hi! you are the first person i’ve encountered on the internet – in any investment blogs or online talking about Consun.
I noticed the same things you’ve noted re – earnings and cash multiples – in ’19 andtook a position then, and topped up in ’20 when it was depressed due to the one-off write-off and integration of the Yulin acquisition.
Keen to connect if you’re open to it.
Good pick! IJW pitched it to me, I should have listened, well I did listen by I felt I had enough HK Smalllcaps at the time
Yeah I am eyeing China Lilang now, courtesy of TheValuePendulum on SA. 10-12% fw dividend yield, 6-7x FW PE, 30% net cash position. Very high ROIC and profit margins. Large historical dividend payout. Company strikes me a bit as a sort of Chinese Hugo Boss. Historically it traded between 8-13x PE.
But already got 40% in HK small caps, and the Taiwan tensions are starting to make me nervous. How do you get comfortable with the Taiwan situation?
Nice post. I had been wondering if you will write about this event 🙂
I also had an eye on this stock but I waited for it to drop a bit after the first profit alert.
It never dropped and I missed the rocket completely.
A very good lesson learned for me and your post enlightens me even further in several aspects.
Thanks for sharing 🙂
Thanks Tua, lets catch the next one together!
Btw, could you help recommend a platform for global stock investing?
Brokers in my country have very limited options and I am looking for something with better coverage and fees.
Congrats again on this position. Well played 🙂
Interactive Brokers is really good. I am using that. Very cheap currency conversion, and you get most major markets. And trading costs are very low as well.
The only downside is, if you do have a problem with something, customer service is somewhat mediocre. Since it is a very automated platform.
It all depends what is available in your country..